Void Standard

Tornado study companion

Read the map description, follow the shelter’s water supply at each delivery and withdrawal, and compare the battery capacity needed for four communications setups.

Scenario and map

Pages 2 and 3 of the report use a historical tornado to frame a present-day scenario. The map locates three sites on the road network. Blue lines follow selected roads before any closures and serve as reference connections. Dotted links show assumed access between the sites and the road network. The shaded corridor marks the area of assumed tornado damage.

The study simulates truck trips separately. Which roads remain available determines when a delivery can reach the shelter. Confirming actual damage, current access and the suitability of a site for emergency use would require local evidence.

The map uses Maryland State Highway Administration road data and site locations from Maryland’s address locator. Road network · State address locator

The simulation tracks requests, acknowledgments, vehicle movements, water use and backup power as events occur. It compares communications arrangements under matched starting conditions and tests how delivery outcomes change with road access, water storage and the timing of demand.

Water deliveries

In the main comparison on page 4, an early request helped avoid a shortfall. When access to the shelter was cut off, both cases requested water early. Only the case with extra water already at the shelter met demand until the delivery arrived.

Dispatch timing under the main scenario
Dispatch policy Unmet demand (L) Vehicle travel (km)
Request after a shortage 78.0 238.4
Request in advance 0.0 67.8
Starting stock under shelter isolation
Starting condition Water on hand at the start (L) Unmet demand (L)
Original stock 19.5 32.5
Extra water stored 52.0 0.0

Water at each event in Figure 2

The two tables give the plotted observations on page 5. Each row shows the stock remaining just after the event and the total demand that had gone unmet since the start. Delivery increases the stock available for later use. An earlier shortage still counts after more water arrives. Times are elapsed hours, minutes and seconds, rounded to the nearest second. Volumes are in liters (L).

Original stock
Elapsed time (h:mm:ss) Event Water on hand (L) Unmet demand to date (L)
0:00:00 Starting stock 19.5 0.0
4:00:00 Water needed 0.0 6.5
8:00:00 Water needed 0.0 32.5
8:05:52 Truck unloaded 136.5 32.5
12:00:00 Water needed 110.5 32.5
16:00:00 Water needed 84.5 32.5
20:00:00 Water needed 58.5 32.5
24:00:00 Water needed 32.5 32.5
Extra water stored
Elapsed time (h:mm:ss) Event Water on hand (L) Unmet demand to date (L)
0:00:00 Starting stock 52.0 0.0
4:00:00 Water needed 26.0 0.0
8:00:00 Water needed 0.0 0.0
8:05:52 Truck unloaded 104.0 0.0
12:00:00 Water needed 78.0 0.0
16:00:00 Water needed 52.0 0.0
20:00:00 Water needed 26.0 0.0
24:00:00 Water needed 0.0 0.0

What happens when access returns later?

A separate comparison on page 5 changes the length of the closure and the timing of drinking-water demand. With demand spread out, the starting stock covered the shorter closure. It ran short when unloading came later. Unloading time is elapsed from the start of the scenario, rounded to the nearest minute.

Duration of road closure and unmet demand
Road closed (h) Delivery unloaded (h:mm) Scheduled demand, unmet (L) Spread-out demand, unmet (L)
8 8:06 0.0 0.0
10 10:06 0.0 5.3
12 12:06 26.0 19.5

Backup power

Figure 3 on page 6 compares four communications setups over the same continuous operating period. The calculations on page 10 account for how much of a battery’s rated capacity is usable and how much of that energy reaches the equipment. Watts (W) measure power. Watt-hours (Wh) measure energy. A device drawing one watt for an hour uses one watt-hour.

Minimum nominal battery rating per site for 24 hours of continuous operation
Equipment in use Continuous load (W) Minimum battery rating (Wh)
Voice radio 0.74 24.7
Voice radio and short text 0.80 26.7
Voice radio and internet 30.74 1,024.7
Voice radio and internet, higher terminal draw 40.74 1,358.0

These ratings are lower bounds for the continuous load. Sending messages consumes additional energy. In the simulated internet cases that used the smaller battery, power ran out. For the higher-draw terminal paired with the smaller battery, the continuous-load calculation ruled out a full day. The study did not simulate that pairing. In a separate simulation, the larger battery sustained the higher-draw terminal and radio for the full period.

Applying the results

The results depend on when people need water, what is already at the shelter, when roads reopen, and when a truck can finish unloading. For communications, the relevant questions are which messages must reach another operator, whether the operator can acknowledge them, and how long the equipment can run on backup power.

Applying these findings to a community would require checking shelter access, water stocks and demand, driving and unloading times, equipment power draw, and whether operators can communicate from their actual locations. Pages 7–10 of the report discuss the conclusions, assumptions and calculation limits. Page 11 lists the sources.